Appeals court stops short of declaring Donald Trump immune from rape accuser’s defamation claim


Former President Donald Trump.

  • A US federal appeals court stopped short of declaring Donald Trump immune from a defamation lawsuit. 
  • E. Jean Carroll accused Trump of raping her in the 1990s in a Bergdorf Goodman store fitting room. 
  • Carroll sued Trump for defamation in 2019, three years into his presidency. 

A federal appeals court on Tuesday stopped short of declaring Donald Trump immune from author E. Jean Carroll’s defamation lawsuit, saying it needed guidance on whether Trump was acting as US president when he denied raping her.

In a 2-1 decision, the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan asked an appeals court in Washington to weigh in on whether the laws of that district shielded Trump from liability.

The Manhattan court also handed Trump a victory in declaring he was a US government “employee” when he allegedly defamed Carroll, a condition underlying his immunity claim.

A dissenting judge, Denny Chin, would have let Carroll pursue “at least some” claims, saying “Carroll’s allegations plausibly paint a picture of a man pursuing a personal vendetta against an accuser.”

Trump’s lawyer Alina Habba did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Roberta Kaplan, a lawyer for Carroll, said in a statement she was “confident” the District of Columbia court would let the case proceed.

READ | Donald Trump shares Truth Social photo proclaiming him as second only to Jesus

Carroll, a former Elle magazine columnist, accused Trump in a June 2019 book excerpt of having raped her in late 1995 or early 1996 in a fitting room at the Bergdorf Goodman store in midtown Manhattan.

She sued Trump for defamation in November 2019 after Trump, then in his third year in the White House, told a reporter he did not know Carroll, said “she’s not my type,” and accused her of concocting the rape claim to sell her book.

Trump claimed he was shielded from Carroll’s lawsuit by a federal law immunizing government employees from defamation claims, and said letting the case proceed could unleash a flood of frivolous lawsuits whenever presidents spoke.

US District Judge Lewis Kaplan found that Trump was not a government employee, and that even if he were, he acted outside the scope of his employment when talking about Carroll.

In asking the D.C. Court of Appeals to address the second issue, Circuit Judge Guido Calabresi said the matter was “of extreme public importance” and there was genuine uncertainty about the district’s law.

He wrote:

We do not pass judgment or express any view as to whether Trump’s public statements were indeed defamatory or whether the sexual assault allegations had, in fact, occurred.

Chin, in his dissent, said Trump was not a government employee, and was not acting as president by making some of his statements.

“In the context of an accusation of rape, the comment ‘she’s not my type’ surely is not something one would expect the President of the United States to say in the course of his duties,” Chin wrote.

Related Posts

Election polling expert said British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak was being reminded by the voters of Chester that he's got a lot of work to do to ensure his party wins the next general election.

UK’s Labour comfortably beat PM Sunak’s Conservatives to retain parliamentary seat

Election polling expert said British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak was being reminded by the voters of Chester that he’s got a lot of work to do…

People raise their fists as they march during an event in remembrance of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on 23 May 2021.

Minneapolis to pay $50 000 each to 12 injured by police during George Floyd protests

People raise their fists as they march during an event in remembrance of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on 23 May 2021. The city of Minneapolis…

US embassy latest target in spate of letter bombs in Spain

US embassy latest target in spate of letter bombs in Spain

The letter bomb was mailed to the US Embassy in Madrid. This is the sixth device to be sent to high profile targets, including one that was sent…

Former FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried (Getty Images)

Former FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried says he ‘didn’t ever try to commit fraud’

Sources say Sam Bankman-Fried secretly moved $10bn of FTX customer funds to his proprietary trading firm, Alameda Research. Bankman-Fried stepped down as FTX CEO on 11 November…

Pixabay

Spain rocked by wave of letter bombs, with the country’s prime minister among those targeted

Spain’s prime minister was targeted by a letter bomb, the interior ministry said on Thursday. The envelope and its contents were similar to those used in four…

(Getty Images)

The UK is looking for someone to help fix SA cities – and is willing to pay R20 million

The UK-SA Urban Resilience Programme wants to enable inclusive, sustainable, and climate-resilient economic development in South African cities. To achieve this, the British High Commission is looking…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *